Privacy · GRC
UK court confirms secret government order to Apple over iCloud encryption
A UK court has confirmed the government secretly ordered Apple to keep access to iCloud accounts, forcing the company to withdraw a key privacy feature for British users.
Ross Grant3 min read

The short version
A UK court has revealed that the British government secretly told Apple to keep a way to access users' iCloud accounts. This forced Apple to remove a privacy feature called Advanced Data Protection for people in the UK. The government says it needs this access to fight crime, but privacy experts are worried about the lack of transparency. The court's decision means millions of UK iCloud users no longer have the same level of privacy as users in other countries.
By the numbers
- millionsBritish iCloud users affected by removal of Advanced Data ProtectionRecorded Future News
- 2027Year scheduled for full hearing on lawfulness of the noticeRecorded Future News
What happened?
A UK court has confirmed that the British government secretly ordered Apple to maintain access to iCloud accounts, forcing Apple to withdraw its Advanced Data Protection feature for UK users. The order was issued through a Technical Capability Notice, which Apple complied with in February 2026. The government had refused to confirm the notice's existence for almost two years, but the Investigatory Powers Tribunal has now made it public. A full hearing on the lawfulness of the notice is set for 2027.
Who is affected
The case centres on Apple and its British iCloud users. In February 2026, Apple withdrew its Advanced Data Protection (ADP) feature for users in the UK. ADP is designed to keep encryption keys only on users’ devices, so even Apple cannot access the contents of iCloud accounts. The withdrawal affected millions of British iCloud customers who lost access to this extra layer of privacy.
What was taken
No user data was stolen or leaked in this case. Instead, the change meant that Apple could once again access the contents of British users’ iCloud accounts if required by law. Before the withdrawal, with ADP enabled, Apple did not have the technical means to access this data.
How the flaw works
The legal tool at the centre of the case is a Technical Capability Notice (TCN). Under UK law, a TCN can require a company to build or maintain the ability to provide access to encrypted data when served with a lawful request. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal confirmed that the British government served Apple with such a notice, demanding that Apple retain the technical ability to access iCloud accounts. This forced Apple to remove ADP for UK users, as ADP would have made it technically impossible for Apple to comply with future lawful requests.
The response
For almost two years, the UK government refused to confirm or deny the existence of the notice, citing national security. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal rejected this approach, ruling that confirming the notice would not harm national security. The court’s decision was based on the fact that the existence of the notice had already been widely reported and discussed by politicians and experts. The government maintains that such powers are necessary to prevent serious crime and terrorism, and that they are subject to strict safeguards. Apple has not commented publicly on the details of the notice but complied by withdrawing ADP for UK users.
What experts say
Experts and academics have criticised the government’s lack of transparency. Some argue that refusing to confirm or deny the existence of such notices is unsustainable and undermines public trust. Tim Stevens of King’s College London said that a default of no comment leaves the government unable to control the story when details emerge. Former GCHQ director Sir Jeremy Fleming has called for more transparency to protect the legitimacy of intelligence agencies. Others, like Andrew Dwyer at Royal Holloway, argue that removing an encryption feature for millions is not the same as a live operation and should be disclosed.
What happens next
The tribunal’s ruling does not decide whether the notice itself is lawful. A full hearing on the legality of the notice is scheduled for the first half of 2027. The government could still withdraw or settle the case before then, but for now, British users remain without ADP on iCloud.
Why it matters
This case highlights the tension between government demands for access to encrypted data and users’ privacy rights. It also shows how secret legal orders can affect the security features available to millions of people. The outcome could set a precedent for how governments and tech companies handle encryption worldwide.
Key points
- A UK court confirmed the government secretly ordered Apple to keep access to iCloud accounts.
- Apple withdrew Advanced Data Protection for UK users in February 2026.
- The government used a Technical Capability Notice to require Apple’s compliance.
- Experts criticise the lack of transparency and the impact on user privacy.
- A full hearing on the lawfulness of the notice is scheduled for 2027.
Sources
Recorded Future News
Reference

